Why Amazon is requesting managers to assign employees low performance ratings

by Time Doctor
amazon performance ratings

The tech company Amazon, well-known for controlling the e-commerce market, has made headlines lately for its contentious performance ranking system. It has been reported that Amazon is pressuring managers to reduce performance points for workers who don’t follow its Return to Office (RTO) guidelines. This article explores the report’s specifics, the effects of implementing such a policy, and Amazon’s and its workers’ responses.

Background of Amazon’s RTO policy

The story started in early 2023 when Amazon made the decision to require the majority of employees to come into work three days a week. By July, this change had become a “return-to-office” policy, requiring staff members to work from specific central locations. Non-compliance with this policy leads to a choice: find a new team or face a “voluntary resignation.”

The controversial performance rating strategy

As per Business Insider, managers at Amazon are now being pressured to give low performance ratings to those not adhering to the attendance policy. Promotions had allegedly been stopped by the corporation in the past for such reasons. Some employees view this approach as a part of a bigger “quiet firing” scheme, which aims to reduce expenses by encouraging employees to quit on their own initiative rather than through harsh terminations without the need for outright terminations.

Employee reactions and company’s stance

Many employees have expressed their dissatisfaction on platforms like Slack, with some even announcing their resignations. One employee criticized the lack of “basic human respect” in the company’s approach. In response, an Amazon spokesperson stated that promotions are based on various factors, including compliance with company policies. The spokesperson also defended the RTO policy, emphasizing its belief in the benefits of in-office collaboration for customers, business, and culture.

How to use Time Doctor’s attendance report and work schedules to save time and increase productivity

Analysis and potential implications

A number of issues regarding workplace dynamics, employee rights, and the changing nature of employment after the epidemic are brought up by this development. It also emphasizes the difficulties businesses have in finding a balance between operational requirements and worker welfare. The corporate world may follow Amazon’s lead and review performance management programs and regulations related to remote labor.


The unfolding situation at Amazon reflects a complex interplay between corporate strategies, employee expectations, and the evolving nature of work. While Amazon upholds its policies as beneficial for the organization’s overall growth, the dissent among employees suggests a need for a more empathetic approach to change management and policy implementation.

View a free demo of Time Doctor

help managers focus on what matters most
time doctor ratings

Related Posts